Schizophrenic First Effort

I got the new Rock Star Supernova CD right before Thanksgiving. After a few listens, my opinion of it remains unchanged. The new Supernova CD is a schizophrenic collection of 11 tunes by second season Rock Star: Supernova contest winner Lukas Rossi, Tommy Lee (Motley Crue), Gilby Clark (Guns and Roses) and Jason Newsted (Metallica). Produced by Butch Walker, the disc almost seems to have been created by two-different bands as the front half of the album has a classic rock-n-roll feel to it, while the back half is more of an angsty-style alt rock record.

The front-half tracks, mostly written by Lee and Walker and occasionally Clarke, have a bouncier, grooving, stadium-rock feel to them. Even if you aren't a fan of the more vapid lyrics in the front half, they're easy to remember and sing-along to. The back half--part written by Lee and part by Clarke--with lyrics provided by Rossi are darker and more introspective. They are deeper, moodier, and not quite as catchy, but infinitely better written; it takes a few listens for them to start to grow on you. But then, there are a few songs that never managed to grow on me (Leave The Lights On, Social Disgrace and Make No Mistake). Which half you prefer depends on how much you like to over-think (or under think) your music.

I'd like to blame the musical schizophrenia on the fact that they only had 6 weeks to create the disc after the end of the show, and they, in theory, had no idea who they were writing for. But, INXS had the same issue and still managed to turn out a good, cohesive CD. They were able to integrate JD Fortune and his style seamlessly. The Supernova boys haven't done as good of a job, despite Lee's assertion that he knew it would be Lukas even before the show aired. In fairness the 5 INXS guys have been together for nearly 30 years. But, they at least had the good sense to pick someone that was stylistically similar to them. Supernova chose someone they thought was hip, would draw a younger audience, but was not a particularly good match to their brash, 80s-arena rock style. So, perhaps the end result is not surprising.

Let's hope they have time to bond out on tour and the second effort, if there is one, is a little more cohesive and less all over the place. It will be interesting to see them on stage at the end of January. My final recommendation--skip buying the whole CD and just download the best tracks.

Download These Tracks: Can't Bring Myself to Light This Fuse
, It's On , Valentine ... The Dead Parade
is quirky, but I like it.

If you've got a couple of extra dollars you haven't expended on Christmas shopping: Headspin , and It's All Love

Don't bother or hit fast forward if you buy the CD: Social Disgrace ,
Make No Mistake--This Is The Take